American Idol Top 5 2025. Platinum ticket winner abi carter came out on top with her rendition of “bring me to life” by evanescence. Read on for a complete breakdown of monday’s results, including the six contestants america voted to keep, the unfortunate singer eliminated from the competition, and the lucky soul who was.

Yes, emmy russell beat out mckenna breinholt and julia. Did emmy russell make ‘american idol’ top 5?